Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingle Roofing- Wagner Metal Supply
Mikinzie Dull

Mikinzie Dull

Content Writer for Wagner SEO & Network Solutions

Learn more about content writing

Metal Roofing Panels vs Asphalt Shingle Roofing

Metal roofing and asphalt shingle roofing are the two leading roofing methods used for Midwestern homes. The two roofing methods have their similarities, but they also have their differences. Replacing a roof can be a big deal for a homeowner. How do you choose which material to use? Both have their pros and cons. Here is a breakdown of what performs best in each category—metal roofing and asphalt shingle roofing.

Cost & Longevity

sustainable roofing-Wagner Metal Supply

sustainable roofing-Wagner Metal Supply

There are a few circumstances to ponder when considering the costs of these two roofing materials. Upon initial installation, asphalt shingles are incredibly more inexpensive than metal roof panels. When comparing shingles and metal panels, asphalt shingles cost less upfront. However, you may want to consider the longevity of the product. Metal panels may cost more upfront, but they perform better in longevity.

The geographical location of your home plays a huge role in the longevity of your roof. The weather conditions your home endures certainly impacts how long it will last over time. Metal roofing takes the win in this category. The lifespan of asphalt shingle roofing is typically 20 years. This isn’t including proper upkeep on shingle group replacements due to harsh weather damaging the roof. The lifespan of a metal roof is 40 years or more in the optimal environment. Metal roofs may cost more upfront, but they will last 2 to 3 times longer than an asphalt shingle roof.



Maintenance is another factor that plays into the longevity of your roof. The better your roof is maintained, the longer it will last! No matter the roofing material you have, it’s crucial to check routinely for debris. If debris rest in one spot for too long, it can severely damage your roof. A grouping of shingles may need replacing if this occurs on asphalt shingle roofing. You may need to replace shingles every once in a while to ensure no leaking occurs. You’re less likely to have to replace your metal roof panels because of their proven durability characteristics. The maintenance of a metal roof is quite simple. Ensure there is no resting debris on the panels, spray the panels down annually, and that’s all! Metal roofs take the win in this category as well!

Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingle Roofing- wagner metal supply 2


Think about what it’s like to hold the two materials in your hand. A metal panel feels exactly how you think it would—sturdy, durable, and solid. Asphalt shingles are great roofing materials, but you can take a shingle and rip it in half with your hands. Many may think metal roofs can be easily dented and damaged. Despite contrary beliefs, metal roof panels are one of the most heavy-duty roofing materials available on the market. All roofs are made to be weather resistant to protect the home. However, metal roofing has been tested and proven to withstand extreme heat, hail, ice, snow, wind, and more. Durability is one of the best characteristics of a metal roof.




Eco-friendly and Energy-Efficiency

Metal roofing is 100% recyclable from the time it’s installed to the time of replacement. Some metal panels are created with previously recycled materials. Due to shingles being asphalt-based, some parts are recyclable, and some are not. Unfortunately, asphalt shingle roofing is not 100% recyclable. Metal panels are the sustainable option between the two.

Many are quick to believe a metal roof makes your house a hot box in the summer and frigid in the winter. That’s a total myth! A metal roof doesn’t get hot to the touch like the hood of your car. The metal roof panel coating formulation actually reflects the rays back into the sky, keeping your home cool in the summer and insulated in the winter. Metal roofing can cut your electricity bill close to half its annual cost! The surface of asphalt shingle roofing is a bit different than metal panels. Asphalt shingles do not have the reflective properties metal panels have. Shingles actually absorb heat. Unfortunately, this could affect your heating and cooling costs. Metal panels are more of a sufficient material if you’re looking for an energy-efficient roofing option.




Color selection

Shingles have come a long way in color selection since years past. Although the colors are more of a muted tone than vibrant, you can find shingles in many colors. Unfortunately, colored shingles fade quite fast. Unlike shingles, metal roofs come in a variety of neutral, vibrant, and earth-tone colors. The great characteristic of metal roofs is their warranties. Wagner Metal Supply carries a 40-year paint warranty on all of our metal panels. We promise the roofs we install will stay vibrant, will not fade, and will look beautiful for a lifetime!




Metal roofing vs. asphalt shingle roofing—what will you choose?

Metal roofing and asphalt shingle roofing both have their pros and cons. Consider your budget, personal preferences, and these other comparisons to help you make your decision. Roof replacements can be a long, frustrating process. Hopefully, you can take these pros and cons to choose the most fitting roofing material for your home.


Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on print
Share on email